India Today reports EU court adviser says Gemini may breach copyright
India Today reports an EU court adviser says Google’s Gemini may breach publishers’ copyright; the ruling is not final, so monitor it.
- Published
- Ecosystem
- AI developer tools
- Exploitation
- No, this is a legal opinion, not a software vulnerability, and the source reports no exploitation
What happened
According to India Today, in a story attributed to Reuters, an adviser to Europe’s highest court said that Google’s Gemini chatbot, when it uses publishers’ articles to answer user queries, may breach copyright rules India Today. This is an advisory opinion, not a court ruling.
India Today reports that the case at the Luxembourg-based Court of Justice of the European Union pits Hungarian website operator Like Company against Google over Gemini. It quotes Advocate General Maciej Szpunar as saying that when an LLM-driven chatbot retrieves a publication from a press publisher’s website, reuses it to generate an answer and gives that answer to the user, “the press publisher’s right may be infringed in certain circumstances.”
According to the same report, Szpunar said Gemini’s answers fall under the publishers’ right of reproduction in two cases: when chatbots access publications by unlawfully circumventing paywalls or other technical barriers, or when they reuse “the form of expression of that publication in a recognisable manner.” He also said copyright does not protect the “mere facts” reported, only the specific form of expression. He said using copyrighted material to train LLMs is “freely permitted under the text and data mining exception.” India Today reports he said there was no evidence Google used the Hungarian publisher’s articles to train Gemini.
India Today reports that a Google spokesperson welcomed the recognition that EU law permits AI training on publicly available information. The spokesperson said Gemini “learns linguistic patterns to create original outputs rather than replicating content” and that publishers have controls, including the ability to opt out. The European Publishers Council, per the same report, said allowing search indexing should be distinguished from authorising AI answers that substitute for original reporting.
Not confirmed: the final ruling and its wording, any fee or penalty for Google, and the full text of the opinion, which the source does not link.
Am I affected?
This is not a software vulnerability. The source names no CVE, affected version or patch, and reports no exploitation.
It may matter if you run a press publication or a service that retrieves and reuses third-party articles in AI-generated answers. According to India Today, the Advocate General’s reasoning turns on circumventing paywalls or technical barriers, and on reusing a publication’s form of expression in a recognisable manner. How the court will apply this is not confirmed. The source says the court follows the majority of its advisers’ non-binding opinions and will rule in the coming months.
What to do now
- Note that the opinion is non-binding. Per India Today, the court will rule in the coming months, and that ruling, not this opinion, sets the legal position.
- If your service retrieves publishers’ content for AI answers, ask your legal counsel how the two cases named by the Advocate General (circumventing paywalls or technical barriers, and recognisable reuse of expression) relate to your product. The source gives no further guidance.
- If you are a publisher, note that Google says it provides opt-out controls for rightsholders, according to India Today. The source does not describe how they work.
- Re-check this advisory when the Court of Justice of the European Union issues its ruling. Nothing beyond the points above is confirmed.